Saturday 29 September 2012

Cinders And Ashes - The Verdict

What does the upcoming season hold for last years champion novice hurdler?

Can the resident of Donald McCain's stable cement the position as the best of the second season hurdler this year?

Will that iconic white blaze on the geldings head be seen romping up the Cheltenham finishing hill to claim the Champion Hurdle in March?

All questions I would imagine you are eager to find out the answer to!

As some of you readers may be aware after reading my previous posts, I don't consider last years crop of novice hurdlers to be all that special in comparison to previous years. There were 3 stand-out novices: Simonsig, Fingal Bay and Boston Bob. My opinion is that these horses are top-class and will hopefully be competing at the sharp end in the upcoming years championship races. Putting that trio to one side, I think the difference between the other novice hurdlers was minimal, Cinders And Ashes included. I think the strength in depth of the 2 mile novice hurdle division to be particularly thin on the ground. The distance between Cinders And Ashes, Trifolium, Darlan and Montbazon was just under 2 lengths. Potential unknown quantities such as Oscara Dara and Alderwood add some spice to the mix. Although, I find it questionable that they are a class above the rest which would place them on a similar level to the trio named above. Therefore, my opinion is the horses that progress into Champion Hurdle contenders this year are more likely to emerge from last years Triumph Hurdle than the Supreme Novice Hurdle.

Cinders And Ashes on route to victory at the Cheltenham Festival 2012
However on reflection, Cinders And Ashes win at the Cheltenham Festival last year was more impressive than I first gave it credit. His victory over Darlan by 1 1/4 lengths included two dreadful errors in the jumping department, at the 4th and more memorably at the last. If he hadn't made that mistake at the last, when the race was at boiling point, he could of won by 3 lengths or maybe more. Of the two lengths between the himself and the 4th placed horse Montbazon, he was over a length clear of Darlan in 2nd. Suggesting he is a notch above the 3 horses who were behind. I know Donald McCain understandably holds this horse in very high regard, but I question whether he holds him as high as his other Champion Hurdle contender Peddlers Cross? He surely can't. Peddlers Cross is out of the very top draw when you look at what he has achieved over hurdles. I know Cinders And Ashes is unproven in that regard and he may improve this year to be as good as his stable mate. If he does I think he will stand high in the pecking order of 2 mile hurdlers this season and I see no reason why he wouldn't be a live Champion Hurdle contender, particularly when the form from last years race looks to be slightly misleading.

The verdict. He appears to save his best effort of the season at the business end of the season. Could be a Champion Hurdle horse, his first couple of runs of the season against the big boys will be very revealing.

Sunday 23 September 2012

The Horse Racing Blog Ten REALLY Dark Horses To Follow National Hunt Season 2012/2013

In this post I will look to inform you about horses I feel have properly gone under the radar for the coming season. I think they could cause a splash at some point this winter and I hope they can all win us a few quid!

1. Broadbackbob



Highly talented novice hurdler last year who was thought of as a serious 2 mile 5 furlong Neptune Novice Hurdle contender. Bought from a small Irish trainer at the beginning of last year after a 6th place finish in the Aintree Champion Bumper the previous Spring, Broadbackbob started life in England with two very easy victories. His first was at Ascot in November over 2 miles where he stayed on better than subsequent Supreme Novice Hurdle winner Cinders And Ashes to beat him by a comfortable length. Highly rated Paul Nicholls novice hurdler Ted Spread was back in 4th. His second came at Newbury in December. He sauntered home to destroy the opposition by 11 lengths over 2 miles 3 furlongs defeating promising hurdlers Polisky and Carrigmorna King. Carrigmorna King was second to Ambion Wood in the European Breeders Fund novice hurdle final at Sandown the last Saturday before the Festival later in the season. His next target was the Neptune Novices Hurdle Trial on Festival Trials day at Cheltenham in January. Going off a short priced favourite at 13-8 he was unlucky to finish second. Having travelled into the race like the winner he jumped the last in front and stumbled badly on landing losing momentum. Batonnier was able to pick up the pieces and charge up the finishing hill to best effect to defeat Broadbackbob by 3 lengths. It was later revealed that Broadbackbob had chipped a hock while racing at Cheltenham and that would go some way to explaining why he hung left the whole way up the run-in that day. Finishing a 3 length second was a pretty good effort with all things considered. Unfortunately, the injury meant he was out for the season. If he had made his target at the Festival I'm convinced he wouldn't have sniffed Simonsig, but think he would have probably been placed. The plan is to go novice chasing this winter. I think he is a welcome recruit to the novice chase ranks and he could feature in many of the main races this season. He is my idea of the the 2 mile 5 furlong Jewson Novice Chase winner currently, but I would expect that 2 1/2 miles is about as far he would want to go. He has shown he has plenty of speed to win races over 2 miles so dropping back to the shortest trip is also an option. However, Nicky Henderson is potentially double handed in those ranks with Simonsig and Tetlami maybe going novice chasing too this year. I would like to think he is more than good enough to mix it with the very best novice chasers this season without maybe being quite good enough to take on the Simonsigs of this world.

2. Hollow Tree



Brave, tough, game, never give up-er. All words to describe a horse that could take up the mantle of being the new 'Lough Derg'. Hollow Tree was a new recruit off the flat to Donald McCain last year and proved not to be the most talented of last years juveniles, but Jesus he was genuine in defeat. Whatever was asked of him he duly did his best and you couldn't help but admire the horse! He was progressive last year. After running a solid enough race in defeat behind Hinterland at the Open Meeting in November, he went and won the Grade 1 Future Champions Novice Hurdle at Chepstow. Behind him in 2nd that day was subsequent Triumph Hurdle winner Countrywide Flame. His next task was a bit more difficult when competing in the Triumph Hurdle Trial at Festival Trials Day. In hindsight, the race had massive strength in depth with classy animals such as Grumeti, Pearl Swan and Baby Mix all entered. Once again Hollow Tree ran a really solid race to finish third beaten 3 1/2 lengths. In the actual event two months later Hollow Tree briefly lead as they turned for home after squeezing up the inside of Sadlers Risk. As was the case all year the better horses had another gear and accelerated past him but he plugged on for 7th beaten a total of 10 lengths. I would imagine handicapping will be his game next year. He currently has a rating of 142. I wouldn't be surprised if he is running off a winnable mark. Sadlers Risk who beat him 3/4 length at Cheltenham is rated 148. I don't think he is 6 pounds better than Hollow Tree, he wasn't even a length better than him in the Triumph Hurdle.

3. Teelin Star



I don't know much about this horse. However, I do know he was seriously hot property in the Irish point to point ranks. In the Champion Point to Point Bumper at the Fairyhouse Festival, where previous winners include Simonsig and Last Instalment, he was sent off a red hot favourite at odds of 8-11. The market confidence came after two victories earlier in the season which he had won by a distance and they sounded very very impressive. He was all the rage going into the race at Fairyhouse but wasn't in the shake up. After the amount of market confidence, he flopped horrendously and was beaten 20 lengths into 8th. He got his career back on track with a win at the Listowel Festival the other day. He made all and was never challenged. He wasn't a runaway winner, but he was a very easy 3 length winner from Sam Da Vinci. This horse is a real unknown quantity this year. What he's capable of I don't know. He seems to be a 2 1/2 mile horse but I wouldn't be surprised if he is stepped up to 3 miles, he obviously has winning form in point to points over 3 miles. He has been ridden from the front in his two starts under rules proper and this tells me he stays well. Whether he will stick to bumpers or go novice hurdling is another question I don't know the answer too. The verdict: Keep an eye out. Those guys in the point to point fields are no mugs and know what they're talking about!

4. Baile Anrai


Baile Anrai was a progressive novice chaser last season who I think may have a big handicap win in him at some point this season . Last year he started off as a novice hurdler, his first outing of the season finishing a 'best of the rest' 2nd behind Fingal Bay in the Grade 2 Persian War at Chepstow in October. A decision to head novice chasing was probably made before the season started, his run at Chepstow was designed to blow the cobwebs away and get him race fit for the season. His debut over fences was in the Grade 2 Rising Star Novices Chase at Wincanton. It was a really tough ask and he was about 20 lengths off the pace when he fell at the 4th last, the winner Silviniaco Conti progressed to be a really smart staying novice chaser later in the year. His second and third attempts over fences where much easier tasks and produced two pretty comprehensive victories around Towcester and Leicester. winning by a combined total of 20 lengths. He was then stepped up in class again to renew rivalries with Silviniaco Conti in the Reynoldstown Novice Chase over 3 miles at Ascot. The race was won by Invictus with RSA winner Bob's Worth back in 2nd, Silviniaco Conti was further down the field in 4th. However although Baile Anrai fell at the 4th last, he was right on the coat tails of the main pack, was going well enough and I don't think he would have been out of the picture if he had stood up. In his next run at the Festival in the JLT Speciality 3m handicap chase he ran no sort of race and was a distant 11th beaten 38 lengths. I think the big crowds and the whole occasion in general got to him as he seemed quite buzzy beforehand and he was probably beaten before he set off. Put a line through that run. He finished the season with a very convincing win in a Market Rasen novice chase by 24 lengths, though it wasn't much of a contest. I would imagine he will go handicapping this season. He currently has a rating of 133 and I think he is well in off that mark. At the age of 8 going on 9 I think he has an advantage over other second season chasers as he is probably more mature and this may help him in the hustly bustly handicaps this winter.

5. Wingtips



In the 2012 Triumph hurdle everybody saw the main protagonists at the head of affairs. Countrywide Flame, Grumeti, Dodging Bullets and Hisabaat. But who can name me the horse that finished 5th off the top of their head? The answer is Wingtips. He was an Irish raider trained by Tony Martin at a price of 100-1. While the horses we have all taken notice of headed to Aintree and Punchestown to frank the form. The Punchestown renewal had a certain Wingtips finishing 3rd at 10-1, again running about up to form. Wingtips didn't win a race last year and can still claim his novice status. With another years maturity both physically and mentally Wingtips could be in a position of strength when taking on younger horses with a years experience in the locker. I dont know what Tony Martin has planned for his horse this year. He has a rating of 138, which will mean he will carry weights towards the top end of the handicaps. Hisabaat is a horse that has beaten him twice and is only rated 5 pounds higher at 143, therefore I don't consider him to be well handicapped.This tells me that another year novice hurdling could be on the cards. However, we have seen Tony Martin line up a big handicap win before, with the likes of Dun Doire and Xenophon at the Cheltenham Festival for example. If anyone knows how to find a handicap snip, Tony Martin is at the top of the list. But is Wingtips too highly rated? He may have to lose before he can win next year.

6. Rigidity


Rigidity - Pictured Centre
I think this horse is underrated. He ran some very good races in the most competitive 2 mile handicap hurdles of the year last season. He was second to Raya Star in the Ladbroke handicap hurdle at Ascot, jumping the last near enough in front, Raya Star beat him only half a length. He was then 8th in the Betfair Hurdle behind Zarkandar at Newbury in February. He was bang there at the third last and was just starting to fade at the second last when Darlan's crashing fall severely hampered him and ended all chances of victory. I think he did well to plug on and finish 8th in the end. A stinker in the Martin Pipe at the Festival followed, I don't know why, but he was so bad it was untrue. Something can't have been right. Anyway, I don't think this horse is good enough to be winning Betfair Hurdles and so on, but I do think he may be good enough to win a competitive handicap somewhere else in the season over 2 miles or maybe 2 1/2 miles. His last run at Cheltenham was over 2 1/2 miles and I think this may be his ideal trip as he has been slightly outpaced when the race has hotted up in the 2 mile handicap hurdles. He currently has a rating of 133 and I think off that mark, bearing in mind he still only 5, there is still improvement to come.

7. Grandouet



Just before I start, I have to admit it pains me to reveal my opinion on Grandouet. This is due to my judgement agreeing with one of my racing comrades. I think this is the first time we have seen eye to eye on anything to do with horses, basically because he is a blind follower of the Nicky Henderson yard (although having seen him play cricket, you would understand why he would need to do it blindly!) I also resent the success he had at the Festival last year, but wasn't surprised he wasn't able to tip a winner that wasn't trained by his 'man crush' Mr Henderson. I believe Grandouet to be the forgotten horse of the upcoming national hunt season. He was extremely unlucky to fall at the second last at Wincanton when running all over Celestial Halo in early November last year. Reappearing in an intermediate hurdle at Haydock two weeks later he won doing handstands, pulling effortlessly clear of Marsh Warbler and Rigidity to win by 8 lengths. He was then stepped up in class to compete in the International Hurdle at Cheltenham in December, a well known Champion Hurdle trial. There was a question mark over the geldings ability to get up the stiff finishing hill at Cheltenham after he appeared to fade away in the Triumph Hurdle the previous March. That was positively swept away with a crushing win when he powered away up the hill to get the better of subsequent Champion Hurdle runner-up Overturn by 4 lengths. The Champion Hurdle proved that fom to be pretty strong. However, I find it debatable how strong it is when you look at the bigger picture. Was this years Champion Hurdle result a true piece of form? It could be argued that it is, but I don't think Rock On Ruby is 5 1/2 lengths better than Hurricane Fly - so I feel the form is quite muddling. Nonetheless, regardless of how good Overturn is, Grandouet could only beat what was put in front of him. The injury he picked up last year to prevent him competing in the Champion Hurdle was obviously very serious. Nicky Henderson was quoted as saying at his owners open day that: 'there had been some scary moments'. Thankfully, it appears he has made a full recovery and if he recaptures the form he was in last year, I see no reason why he can't be a serious contender for the Champion Hurdle crown in 2013.

8. Comeonginger



If Tistory is the highest rated novice hurdler at Nicky Henderson's yard for this upcoming season, Comeonginger fills that position at Paul Nicholl's stables. Owned by Paul Barber, he has won two point to points, never coming off the bridle in the second, his jockey described his win as 'an exercise gallop'. He is a full brother to ill-fated Cheltenham Festival winner Brindisi Breeze. That's about as much as I can tell you to be honest! He's certainly an exciting novice hurdler for the 2012/2013 season.

9. Oscara Dara



Oscara Dara is one of the horses who changed stables after Alan Fleming migrated to Ireland. He was moved to Nicky Henderson's yard and caused a bit of a splash. His last run for Fleming was a second place finish in a relatively hot bumper behind his current stable mate Mono Man. Following a set-back, his debut for Henderson was delayed for just over a year, reappearing at Sandown on the best day of the year (9th March is my birthday) he won very impressively by 20 lengths. For his next task he was stepped up in trip to tackle the best novice hurdlers around last year at the Aintree Festival, where he finished 4th behind stable mates Darlan and Captain Conan. Still relatively fresh he was sent straight to Punchestown for a 2 mile novice hurdle. Sent off a short priced 11-8 favourite he stayed on well to assert on the run-in to score by 3 1/2 lengths. Henderson said on his owners open day that the horse had matured well over the summer, he predicted that he would be much improved this year. The plan is to go novice chasing this winter, behind the stables most promising novices Simonsig and Captain Conan, he probably plays third fiddle. He has plenty of pace but I think a step up in trip will benefit him, he should be a smashing 2 1/2 miler. Nicky Henderson was very positive at his open day: 'If everything goes to plan, he's a very serious prospect'.

10. Samain



Another horse I can't tell you much about I'm afraid! He's won 3 bumpers in Ireland since he joined Willie Mullins after being purchased by Gigginstown Stud. He was a hot prospect for the Champion Bumper the year before last before he picked up an injury. The injury kept him off the track throughout last year but he's expected to return this winter. He's now 6 going on 7 so he will be one of the older horses going novice hurdling this year. A wiser head and advanced physical maturity should help him when competing against his less experienced rivals. He looks like a chaser in the making but whether he will head straight novice chasing this year and skip novice hurdling I don't know. In his bumpers the gelding out-stayed his rivals. He never accelerated away from them to be visually impressive, but was always in total command at the winning post. I just hope his injury wasn't so severe that he will never be able to fulfil his potential.

Wednesday 19 September 2012

The Horse Racing Blog Ten Dark Horses To Follow For The National Hunt Season 2012/2013

1. Peddlers Cross



Some may ask how a Champion Hurdle runner-up is a dark horse? The answer is simple. 2012/2013 is a recovery mission for Peddlers Cross. He was last seen finishing well down the field in the 2m 5f Jewson Novice Chase when favourite at the Cheltenham Festival, after which his trainer Donald McCain immediately stated his stable star would revert back to hurdles in 2012/2013. That run at Cheltenham brought to an end what was ultimately an unsuccessful novice chasing campaign. His efforts over fences never replicated his brilliance over the smaller obstacles. It seemed the natural athleticism and spine-tingling speed at which he could get from one side of a hurdle to the other were not present when he jumped a fence. I would attribute this to being his main downfall and would help to explain why he never appeared to recapture the form he displayed over hurdles. It was undisputed that he was top class over hurdles and I think the gelding has sneaked under the radar a bit for this coming season. At 25-1 ante-post for the Champion Hurdle, I think he is real value assuming that all is well with his health. I say this as I think there may have been a bit of a problem with Peddlers Cross last year. Donald McCain constantly re-iterated that his horse was working as well as ever at home, but a decision on his Cheltenham Festival target was consistently delayed. Whether he was simply papering over the cracks, or connections were running scared of Sprinter Sacre, I don't know, I'm afraid. But I'm 99% certain there was more to it than met the eye. My gut feeling tells me that Peddlers Cross was not firing on all cylinders. Hopefully after a summer off and some time to recharge the batteries, this horse will justify my faith in him when putting up bold displays in the top class 2 mile
hurdles this year.

2. Champion Court



The horse I call the 'bridesmaid'. Always in the shake up, never runs a bad race,  but always finds one too good. He was 2nd on numerous occasions in novice chases last year, notably to Grands Crus at the Open Meeting in November and then more recently to Sir Des Champs at the Festival. Like so many front-running chasers he races with real zest and loves to attack his fences. It just depends on whether there is one good enough to get passed him. There are never two, but nearly always one ! In my opinion he is a 2 and a half miler. He gets every yard of the trip and making it a stamina test through his front-running style is the ideal way to ride him. Stepping him up to 3 miles means he is less effective when ridden from the front. Unfortunately, finishing runner up on so many occasions has come at a cost. Getting so close to the top class novices (but being so far ahead of the others !) has meant his handicap rating of 155 is very similar to those who have been his conquerors. Grands Crus is rated 157 and Silviniaco Conti, 156. Therefore if these horses run up to their ratings next year, the case of 'seconditus' he caught last year could be present again in 2012/2013. However, he may well still be on the upgrade and second season chasers have excellent records in the big handicaps, such as the Paddy Power Gold Cup. His trainer, Martin Keighley, has stated that his horse will probably start in a graduation chase as he thinks it may not be fair for his stable star to run consistently well in handicaps and ruin his handicap mark. In conclusion, I feel the coming year will be another difficult one for Champion Court unless he has considerably improved over the summer. I expect to see him living up to the name I have dubbed him once again this year. He is however a swinger certainty, so make sure he is on your slip, whoever else you may fancy!

3. Tistory

Carries the tag of being the most exciting novice hurdler at Nicky Henderson's yard this year. He is owned by Judy Wilson whose blue and green silks are synonymous with crowd favourites such as French Opera and Greenhope. Coincidently Tistory is a half brother to Punchestowns, possibly the most talented horse to carry Judy Wilson's colours. The gelding has won three bumpers, two in France and one in England - a battling win by 3/4 length at Ludlow on March 1st. This win brought about plans for a trip over the Irish Sea to compete in the Champion Bumper at Punchestown. However, a ruling about the races Tistory had won in France prevented him from competing.  For those who care, the bumpers he won were non-thoroughbred, as such they are classified as flat races in Ireland whereas they are not in England. Basically, making things pointlessly complicated. Nonetheless, the bottomless underfoot conditions probably would have meant the horse would've been withdrawn anyway. Nicky Henderson was speaking at his owners open day on Sunday where he was happy to express his high hopes for the novice hurdler this year. His exact description was, 'Tistory is undoubtedly one of our big hopes for novice hurdle honours this year'. In simpler words. This horse is one to have on your betting slip.

4. Last Instalment



Which horse was the best staying novice chaser in Ireland last year? First Lieutenant , Last Instalment or Sir Des Champs? (wouldn't mind to be Michael O'Leary when you think of these 3 horses, however much I dislike flying with Ryanair!) Unfortunately, we were deprived of seeing the true outcome last year when Last Instalment was injured in action whilst winning the Dr P.J Moriarty novice chase at Leopardstown in February. The 7 year old is unbeaten over fences, defeating some high class horses in doing so. Most notably Cheltenham Festival runner-up First Lieutenant and 3rd place finisher Four Commanders. Up until now, he has readily swept aside his competitors in a rather nonchalant manner. He just carries on galloping until he grinds his rivals into the ground. Very similar to how Denman used to race. I'm not saying he has the quality of Denman, but his main attribute is to stay, not to do his competitors for toe! In other words he could be put into the bracket as 'an old fashioned, proper staying chaser'. His victory over First Lieutenant at Leopardstown at Christmas was very impressive. First Lieutenant couldn't live with the Phillip Fenton trained gelding that day. Last Instalment appeared to crack him by simply galloping him into the ground. However, I am aware that First Lieutenant runs his best race at Cheltenham in the spring on a stiff track when the ground is firmer. Bearing this in mind, I think its a fair argument that First Lieutenant's efforts in the winter are not a fair reflection of how good he is. However, at the end of the day, he was thumped by Last Instalment over Christmas and I don't think he ran that poorly that day. Last Instalment then proceeded to win the Dr P.J Moriarty at Leopardstown in his normal nonchalant manner, while injured I hasten to add. Also I think the fact he is a true 'staying chaser' is to his benefit. I can see him 'out-staying' horses in long distance races this year. If the Gold Cup is his main target, I think a stiff track such as Cheltenham and a true dog eat dog finish up the hill will play to his strengths.

5. Balder Succes



When stepped up in class to the top quality juvenile races last spring his form figures read: fell after a mile and unseated rider at the 1st. So we have no possible inclination of how good he may be. However if we take his 3 wins prior to Cheltenham and Punchestown, he could be anything. The gelding won in ultra-impressive style on all 3 occasions and was not asked a question in all 3 races. When he went to Cheltenham all the talk surrounding this horse was around whether he would he be able to act on a sounder surface as he had done in those 3 crushing wins when the ground had more give. His starting price of 15-2 tells you that nobody really knew and unfortunately we still don't! The TV screen didn't give you a very conclusive view of his fall in the Triumph at Cheltenham. I'm just wondering whether they were going half a stride to quick for him on the firmer ground? He didn't seem to be struggling before his fall, but you wonder as the fall came at the hurdle after the pace was injected into the race. The race at Punchestown was just one of those days. He was awkward at the first and left Choc Thornton with no chance but to exit via the side door. Oh well, as Grandma always says, there's always tomorrow! Your guess as to how good Balder Succes is are as good as mine. One thing I do think is that he will relish a step up in trip as 2 miles is on the sharp side for him. I think 2m 4f is his optimum distance and he will be stepped up to this trip after a warm up race, maybe in what was the Greatwood Hurdle at Cheltenham at the Open Meeting.

6. New Years Eve



If you attended a 2012 Cheltenham Festival preview evening in Newmarket last year, you will be aware of the supreme confidence surrounding one horse - and it wasn't Frankel for once! It was about a horse from John Ferguson's yard who had won 2 egg and spoon bumper races around Ludlow and Market Rasen. Heading into the Champion Bumper, New Years Eve appeared to be the only horse that could win the race. He was backed into 9-2 favourite and the amount of confidence behind him was unbelievable! Unfortunately, the event turned into a bit of a damp squid when the gelding finished 2nd having failed to quicken past Champagne Fever up the hill. In hindsight, only one horse has headed Champagne Fever and New Years Eve probably came closest to repeating this in the most competitive bumper of the year. Ferguson then sent the horse to Punchestown for their Champion Bumper in April. The race was run in a bog and New Years Eve was effectively pulled up on the home bend and finished walking across the line. I think he simply hated the ground. The fact is that this horse is obviously extremely talented and could be a very exciting recruit to the novice hurdle ranks this year. I think he may prefer good ground, if this is the case it would possibly suggest he will run his best races in the spring when the ground dries out. Bearing this in mind he may be a Supreme Novice hurdle contender for the Festival 2013.

7. Montbazon



One of my favourite horses in training. I've always got the feeling that Alan King thinks this horse could be exceptionally good. He is one of three horses at his yard that are stepping up from the novice hurdle ranks this year that all look high class. Grumeti, Balder Succes and Montbazon, which one is the best? The answer is...pass. I have no idea. But I've always got the sense that this horse has a real soft spot in his trainers heart. He was near enough the best bumper horse around the year before last. That campaign culminated in a second place finish behind Steps To Freedom in the Aintree bumper. Although, I am never convinced how strong a form line this race is with previous winners such as Megastar, Sitting Tennant and Pangbourne not going on to be anything special. However, Montbazon did beat home that year high class novice hurdlers such as 2012 Supreme Novice Hurdle winner Cinders And Ashes and Broadbackbob. He started last year in the bumper at the Open Meeting at Cheltenham in November, which I was there to see. He finished third but didn't look anywhere near properly tuned up and looked a bit fat in addition to Alan Kings horses running poorly for all 3 days of the meeting. His novice hurdle campaign began at Newbury with a difficult debut task against the classy Colour Squadron, going off at 5-1, he finished a creditable 2nd, beaten a length. He then won a confidence building exercise around Plumpton against a bunch of trees before heading back to Newbury to renew rivalries with Colour Squadron. In the meantime Colour Squadron would have probably won the Tolworth Hurdle at Sandown if he could run in a straight line! Montbazon won that day at Newbury putting in their place other promising hurdlers such as All The Aces and Vulcanite, although he was assisted by Colour Squadron's fall at the second last, I think that Montbazon just about had him held. The end of year assessment loomed at Cheltenham the following month. Starting at 15-2 in the Supreme Novices Hurdle he never quite jumped with the slickness and fluency required to stay in contention in the 2 mile helter skelter opener to the Festival. However, stay in contention he did! He was bang there at the last with eventual winner Cinders And Ashes whose mistake at the last, where he knocked the hurdle flat, probably put off Montbazon who put in an awkward leap at the hurdle. The gelding kept tabs with the top four and finished 1 3/4 lengths 4th. Not a bad effort! A real improvement on his other runs where horses he had beaten before such as Vulcanite and Colour Sqaudron were well over 10 lengths behind him. I don't know what Alan King has in plan for this horse this year. I would imagine the plan is to stick to hurdles for another season and we may see him entered in the top 2 mile hurdle races this year. I remember Alan King saying Montbazon was quite hard to train because he suffers with chronic sore shins. Bearing this in mind, I don't know how many times he will appear this season but I would advise you to look out for him when he does.

8. Tetlami



Probably Nicky Henderson's 2nd best 2 mile novice hurdler last year after Darlan - who was probably  just about the best of them all. After two pretty promising novice hurdle victories at Sandown and Kempton beating decent horses such as Vulcanite and Knight Pass, he won a 'jumpers bumper' at Kempton as his prep run for a crack at the Supreme Novice Hurdle. He was bang in contention at the third last and looked a likely winner before fading to finish 9th beaten 12 lengths. However, if you look at the scope of this chestnut you would say he is made for chasing. I don't know what the plan is for this horse but I hope he goes novice chasing this winter. This is because I would imagine he will be a better chaser than he was a hurdler. I also think he has the ability to be a really smart smart horse over 2 or 2 1/2 miles where he can use his natural speed and scope to take lengths out of his rivals through jumping with accuracy at real pace. Personally, I think he fits the mould of a smart novice chaser who could put in a bold display in the Grand Annual at The Festival. Previous winners such as Bellvano, Oh Crick and Pigeon Island were all novices.

9. Sonofvic



This is a contentious selection. He would have been in many peoples ten to follow at this time last year after a promising hurdler career was switched to novice chasing. He was supposed to excel last year over the bigger obstacles and was the source of much ante-post RSA betting interest. However, not all went to plan. A very good effort behind Grands Crus on his debut meant he was only beaten 2 lengths by the ante-post RSA favourite. It was his next run on New Years Day that baffled me. Constant re-iteration that he was really classy from his trainer Paul Nicholls and his promising debut run meant there was massive market confidence behind the horse as he was sent off 6-5 favourite. He was a staying on 5th when he slipped on landing taking the fence at the top of the hill and left Ruby Walsh with almost no chance. Somehow he managed to keep the partnership intact and finish the race aboard the 7 year old. Disregarding Ruby Walsh's brilliance in the saddle, he wasn't winning the race and it was ultimately a poor effort when everything looked so positive. After that his novice chase campaign was scrapped so he could mature a bit more mentally and physically. Remember this horse has only seen a racecourse 5 times so is still relatively inexperienced. He was kept off the track until the Cheltenham Festival came along in March where he was entered in the Pertempts Final 3 mile hurdle race. Although he fell at the last and the Racing Post description says 'weakening', he was only 7 lengths 5th at the time. For a horse who had never run in a hustly bustly handicap and was competing against very experienced handicappers, I thought it was a really good effort. With another summers maturing I think Sonofvic could prove to be the horse that everyone has been crowing about for the last 2 years. By fulfilling his potential I expect to see him putting in bold displays in staying novice chases this season. I think he is a horse that needs a stiff track and a stamina test to see him in his best light. Therefore, I would imagine he will be a regular visitor to tracks such as Cheltenham, Chepstow and Newbury.

10. Mount Benbulben



Gordon Elliot normally has one horse lined up for a victory at the Cheltenham Festival and he's normally pretty vocal in doing so! At the 2011 Festival he had two winners in the shape of Chicago Grey and Carlito Brigante. Both had been beautifully laid out for their races and both won with a bit in hand too. At the 2012 Festival he didn't have a winner.  I suppose you can never expect too much from the most competitive racing festival in the world ! However, the horse he was very vocal about this year was Mount Benbulben. Apparently the gelding had been working superbly on the gallops and had a brilliant chance in the Albert Bartlett Hurdle on Gold Cup Day. He was comprehensively beaten the best part of 20 lengths, finishing 7th. His form before that run had stacked up pretty well. In previous runs he had beaten subsequent Punchestown Champion Bumper winner Lovethehigherlaw around Limerick. Over hurdles he had beaten subsequent Galway Hurdle winner Rebel Fitz and he had also got the better of Jetson who went on to win the valuable Pertemps Hurdle Qualifier at Leopardstown over Christmas. The only horse who had beaten him over hurdles last year was Boston Bob, the best novice hurdler to come out of Ireland last year. I think there were 3 or 4 competing to be the second best and this horse was right up there. I don't know quite what happened at Cheltenham. Perhaps he ran not 100% like many of Gordon Elliot's horses did that week or maybe his first effort on good ground and over 3 miles had caught him out. I think he may require a bit of cut in the ground, but if he does get it, I think this horse could be a serious threat in staying hurdles in Ireland this year.

Thursday 13 September 2012

The Horse Racing Blog Jumpers Ten To Follow 2012/2013

1. Big Bucks



How could I leave him out? Without doubt the greatest staying hurdler there has ever been. Although his victories are never by margins that stick in the memory, he looked as good as ever in the spring when claiming the World Hurdle at Cheltenham and then the Liverpool Hurdle at Aintree. It is hard to argue that he won't win the 2013 renewals next year. With potential high class staying novice hurdlers from 2012 such as Fingal Bay and Boston Bob probably heading novice chasing next year, there seems to be little new competition that may be a threat to Big bucks when he looks to extend his 17 race winning streak. At the age of 10 when the World Hurdle comes around in 2013, some may say he is heading into the latter stages of his career. However, I doubt this will be too much of a hindrance to the gelding and I would expect him to still be plenty strong enough to claim a 5th World Hurdle and subsequently a 5th Liverpool Hurdle next Spring. This should be in addition to winning the: Newbury Hurdle on Hennessy day, the Longwalk Hurdle and potentially the Cleeve Hurdle on Festival trials day in January. I assume 2013 will be another year when he truly cements his dominance on the 3 mile hurdle division.

2. Sprinter Sacre



The most exciting novice chaser I can recall in my relatively short horse racing following. Unbeaten over fences, this alpha-male of a horse defeated his rivals in a manner that can only be described as 'spanked'. The resident of Seven Barrows stables is a 2-1 ante-post favourite for next years 2 mile Queen Mother Champion Chase and in my eyes, rightly so. Described as an 'aeroplane' last year, his jockey Barry Geraghty was certainly a 'pilot' in the geldings victories effectively just doing the steering. The rest was left to Sprinter Sacre , and jeez he delivered! The highlights of his novice campaign were taking the Arkle Trophy at the Festival in March and following up this with the Maghull Novice Chase at Aintree. Both looking what my mate would describe as 'The Badgers Nadgers'. Being a new-comer to the championship 2 mile chase division places an element of doubt that inexperience could be his undoing. However, the competition he will face is either ageing in the case of Sizing Europe or quite frankly not good enough in the case Gauvain. His stable mate and last years winner of the Queen Mother Finians Rainbow also looks like being stepped up in trip for a crack at the King George. Consequently, I don't consider his level of inexperience to be a problem. Look at the way he demolished the 2 mile seasoned chasers in the Game Spirit at Newbury in February for example. The only thing that can surely beat Sprinter Sacre, is Sprinter Sacre. This horse is a banker.

3. Sir Des Champs



Long thought as a future Gold Cup horse by his trainer Willie Mullins, this Gigginstown owned gelding is already ante-post favourite for the 2013 renewal at 6-1. 2012 was a progressive year for Sir Des Champs. Starting off in relatively serene surroundings at Fairyhouse, two more novice chase wins followed before the highlight of his season came when winning the 2m 5f Jewson Novice Chase at the Cheltenham Festival. He powered away up the hill from Champion Court that day like a really good horse. I distinctively remember Dad backing him at 14-1 ante-post which bought the family a nice Chinese that evening. The peking duck was yummy as ever! What made it even more tasty was that I had a little dabble on the Irish raider too! Looking forward to this year, I expect to see Sir Des Champs putting up bold displays in the championship 3 mile chases across the Irish Sea. I feel his main quality his the ability to stay and jump in a manner that doesn't exert too much energy. This could be crucial if he is to challenge for the Gold Cup in March as there are many rivals who will be around to pick up the pieces. These horses could be Bobs Worth, Long Run or The Giant Bolster. For those of you who have noticed I haven't included Flemenstar in this summary, to be honest with you, I was torn to choose between him and Sir Des Champs. I sided with the latter due to feeling he will get every yard of the 3 mile trips he will be covering this year whilst Flemenstar hasn't gone beyond 2m 4f in his career as of yet. I feel Sir Des Champs will out-stay Flemenstar. Simple as that. Although I have very little confidence behind this theory. Nonetheless, my gut instinct tells me that Sir Des Champs will fund many more takeaways this winter in the Down household!

4. Hurricane Fly



This entrant at no.4 doesn't need much of an introduction. The apple of his trainer Willie Mullins eye, his constant reiteration of the brilliance his stable star is capable of was vindicated in the 2011  Champion Hurdle and more recently in the Irish Champion Hurdle. The latter performance was rated as 'his best ever' by Mullins and it seemed, on that form, the defence of his crown at the Festival was a formality. It obviously wasn't with the 8 year old finishing 3rd. He then reappeared at the Punchestown Festival to defend his Rabobank Champion Hurdle where he won in a style that was similar to his run in the Champion Hurdle. I'm not sure whether he was quite himself last spring, I going to attribute that to his brilliant win in the Irish Champion Hurdle taking more out of him than first thought. I am more than willing to give him another chance and I have no doubt there isn't a horse than can live with him in 2 mile hurdles when he his on top form. I don't consider last years Supreme Novice to be the best we've seen and if that judgement proves to be correct then something like Cinders And Ashes surely can't be good enough to get the better of the Fly. Lets just hope horses racing equivalent of Ledley King arrives fit and healthy at all his intended targets!

5. Simonsig:




Cemented himself as the top novice hurdler over 2m 4f last term with two devastating victories at Cheltenham and Aintree in the spring. Nicky Henderson believes a drop back in trip would suit rather than a step up, as he feels Simonsig has a lot of natural speed which would be best utilised over the shorter 2 mile trip. His high cruising speed should assist him over 2 miles and help his jockey Barry Geraghty get his rivals off the bridle. Also his natural scope would also suggest that jumping a fence should not be an issue, in fact Henderson said the reason he ran over 2m 4f last term was to help his jumping as hurdles seemed to just 'get in the way'. Simonsig is definitely a horse for the ten to follow and is ante-post favourite for the Arkle at 3-1. This short price would suggest there is a lot of confidence behind the grey. I expect to see him competing in the top class novice chases this year and he is in my ten to follow principally as my ante-post selection for the Arkle in 2013.

6. Fingal Bay:




Campaigned at staying novice hurdles last year. Fingal Bay could not be faulted only losing in the Sefton at Aintree (prefers softer ground and interfered by fallen horse were adequate excuses) whilst also racking up wins in the Challow hurdle and at The Open Meeting. He is almost certain to be stepped-up to 3 miles which would suggest that either the RSA or the World Hurdle are potentially his main targets. To win those races the main characteristic that a horse requires, in such a grueling contest is to stay. In my opinion this is Fingal Bay's greatest attribute. An issue may be whether he goes novice chasing this year or delay the inevitable until 2013/2014. The dilemma Philip Hobbs faces is whether to take on Big Bucks (the greatest of them all!) in the World Hurdle and give the horse another year to mature and gain experience. Or whether to take a chance this year but then possibly leave the horse with less experience when he takes on the big boys in the high class staying chases the following year? In my view this horse is a top quality animal and will almost certainly be seen in Gold Cups of the future. The gelding is 10-1 ante-post favourite for the RSA and he is my likely winner of the race. An element of doubt about whether he will go novice chasing and a liking for some cut in the ground which has not been present at the Cheltenham Festival in recent times would worry me though. However, I feel he is a gamble worth taking as I feel he is top top class. When a trainer describes one of their horses as 'phenomenal' like Phillips Hobbs has, you take note and listen.

7. Hunt Ball:




The story of the 2011/2012 season, there isn't a lot I can say about Hunt Ball that hasn't already been said. The Anthony Knott owned gelding rose an astonishing 88 pounds in the weights last term, that's over 6 stone!  I know some may argue that he can't improve much more and to be honest I agree with you. He proved he can compete with the top class 3 mile chasers at Aintree and he definitely appeared to stay. I think he is a horse who will relish a stamina test this year. He is in my ten to follow as my ante-post selection for the Hennessy at Newbury in November and then if things go well, he may well go to the Gold Cup. I hope this horse can collect the bonus points on offer for these races. I feel he meets a few trends the Hennessy has created. Apart from the fact the race seems a logical place for the 7 year old start his campaign. The fact he is 7 is to his advantage, 5 winners in the last 10 years being aged 7. Also 6 of the last 10 winners have been rated between 142-158, Hunt Ball currently has a rating of 157. I think there is potential the handicapper hasn't got him quite yet. He is at least as good as, or better than, Medermit and Burton Port for example. They are rated 167 and 166 respectively. I still think he may be a few pounds to the good! Is the dream still on for the 2013 Gold Cup? Could we have another winners enclosure classic like last year? If his enigmatic owner Anthony Knott (pictured above riding his horse back into the winners enclosure with jockey Nick Schofield at Wincanton) is around  you can almost guarantee we will. 'B****r the cows!' Comment of the year.

8. Rebel Fitz



It is always questionable where the Galway Hurdle winner will venture after their success in the summer and more importantly, whether they will have any more success in the coming winter. Looking at previous winners such as Moon Dice and Oslot, the Galway Hurdle race win has been their last due to their rise in the weights. Consequently, like Oslot, Moon Dice may have to head novice chasing in search of races where he can still be competitive. But, and this a big but, this years winner in Rebel Fitz looks to be something a bit special. The gelding turned up at Cork later in August this year in another handicap hurdle, where at a starting price of 4-11 favourite, he promptly swept aside solid handicappers such as Sailors Warn and Fosters Cross. The starting price told you the story, they knew! From the relatively unknown yard of Michael Winters, Rebel Fitz has progressed to a rating of 155. If you look at the ratings he is much higher in the weights than Moon Dice was after his Galway hurdle win, however I think this gelding may well be a bit better than a handicapper such as Moon Dice. In my opinion this horse has so much progression to come that he could be a championship racehorse. Don't be surprised if you see this animal appear in the Champion Hurdle next year. It may sound a bit optimistic but there's something that stinks about this horse and I wouldn't be surprised if he's still well in off a mark of 155.

9. Salut Flo




I may be criticised for thinking through my heart rather than my head here, whereby the 33-1 I missed ante-post for the Byrne Group Plate at the festival is still haunting me. I have put him in my ten to follow principally for the Paddy Power Gold Cup in November where I think he has a fantastic chance. Winning the 2m 5f contest would provide me with some of those precious maximum 25 bonus points. For those of you who want to hear why I think the gelding has a real chance in the Paddy Power Gold Cup please refer to my post 'The Paddy Power Gold Cup Winner' (http://thehorseracingblog1.blogspot.co.uk/2012/09/the-2012-paddy-power-gold-cup-winner.html). If you haven't already done so. The plan is to substitute this horse after the December Gold Cup race at Cheltenham. Will handicap mark will have rocketed skywards following two victories! I will be replacing him with Finian's Rainbow when his main target the King George comes around on Boxing Day.

10. Boston Bob




My judgement of Boston Bob is much the same as the majorities. I believe he was the best novice hurdler in Ireland last year and his defeat in the Albert Bartlett at the Cheltenham Festival came as a bit of a shock. He was the centrepiece of my Union Jack bet that day, although his defeat didn't cost me too much money as I didn't have the best of Gold Cup days. The fact he was my centrepiece displayed I thought he had a great chance. He just seemed to run a bit 'flat', he ran well but not quite as well as we know he can. His performance was similar to Hurricane Fly's run in the Champion Hurdle, just not quite 100%. Coincidently, they both won on that day at Leopardstown when conditions were horrendous. Boston Bob probably had more of a slog than was first thought and I think it may have taken quite a lot out of him. He was expected to move onto Punchestown after Cheltenham where he would get his novice hurdle campaign back on track, but he was not entered. His trainer Willie Mullins' explanation was that he thought Boston Bob had done enough for the year. I interpreted this as something was not quite right and whatever it was that meant he wasn't 100% at Cheltenham was still present later on in the spring. I think the plan is to go novice chasing this winter. He will almost certainly be aimed at the RSA and other staying novice chases in Ireland. I would imagine jumping a fence will not be a problem as he was athletic over his hurdles and he has the scope to jump a fence. He showed he stays last year when he and the ill-fated Brindisi Breeze out-stayed their rivals in the Albert Bartlett in March. I expect many bold displays from Boston Bob this year. However if things don't go to plan I would imagine I will substitute this horse with a staying chaser with the 'National' races coming around later in the season.

Tuesday 11 September 2012

Why Doesn't Jefferson Get The Credit He Deserves?

There have been many feats that have been achieved within the horse racing world that beggar belief.

Michael Dickinson's first 5 home in the 1983 Gold Cup. 

Frankie Dettori's through the card 7 wins on Champions Day at Ascot in 1996.

Aldaniti and Bob Champion's tear-jerking victory in the 1981 Grand National after over-coming an injury and cancer respectively.

Aldaniti and Bob Champion take Beechers on their way to victory in the 1981 Grand National
At the 2012 Cheltenham Festival and then at the Aintree Festival the following month, an accomplishment occurred which I think hasn't received the merit it deserves. 

On the Thursday of Festival week, the 3 mile Pertempts Handicap Hurdle was won by Cape Tribulation beating home Catch Me by 3/4 of a length, with the Paul Webber trained Cantlow a further length back in 3rd. The mount of Denis O'Regan out-stayed his rivals up the famous hill to provide his trainer Malcolm Jefferson with a first Festival win in 17 years after Dato Stars victory in 1985. The victory brought his trainer to tears.

Cape Tribulation winning at the Festival in 
2012

The famous saying 'one brings two' was ever present the following day. On Gold Cup day Jefferson found himself in the famous winners closure once again after Attaglance's win the 2m 4f Martin Pipe Conditional Jockeys handicap hurdle. Ridden by the under-rated Harry Haynes claiming 3 pounds off the geldings back, Attaglance powered gamely up the Prestbury Park finishing hill to get the better of Toner D'Oudairies by a neck with Oscar Nominee a further neck behind in a blanket finish to record a 20-1 victory.

Attaglance


As is common at the Cheltenham Festival, a big handicap win on the biggest stage of them all comes at a sacrifice. The sacrifice is a hike in the weights as the horses rating shoots skywards. Cape Tribulation's victory raised him 8 pounds finding himself a rating of 150 from 142. Attaglance's rating rose 5 pounds from 139 to 144. Such a hike in the weights, when the valuable handicaps are so competitive with all the horses rated so closely together, the next few outings for Cape Tribulation and Attaglance were supposed to be much more difficult. Now "in the hands of the handicapper".



How wrong the handicapper, I and many others were! The following month at Aintree, both horses were turned out by Jefferson. Cape Tribulation heading for the 3 mile handicap hurdle and Attaglance for the 2 mile 4f handicap hurdle. After their rise in the weights both horses carried top weight of 11 stone 12 pounds - Harry Haynes was not able to claim his 3 pound allowance. As we know the results show that both horses recorded amazing follow up victories after their Cheltenham Festival success'.

Both horses were again outsiders. Cape Tribulation was again 14-1 starting price whilst Attaglance was shorter than his Cheltenham excursions at 14-1 also. The fact both were relatively unfancied told you the publics perception of their chances. Although once again, They both pulled the rabbit out of the hat.  

We have seen horses record follow up victories at Aintree after their Cheltenham Festival success before, but these are normally in the championship races. Horses such a Peddlers Cross and more recently Sprinter Sacre are examples. It is extremely rare for a horse to do so in handicap company due to their rise in the weights. However Malcolm Jefferson masterminded not one, but two of these rare feats last spring. A truly astonishing accomplishment!! 

I would imagine Malcolm Jefferrson made a few quid as a result of their victories. I hope he did because I certainly didn't! To be honest Attaglance's Aintree win cost me quite a lot considering the horse finishing second, Tour D'Argent, was the final leg of my patent. Which already contained two winners!!

Tour D'Argent - you owe me some money this season mate!
In my opinion this accomplishment will almost certainly never be repeated and deserves more exposure than it has received. 

Well done Malcolm Jefferson you sly old dog!

Monday 10 September 2012

I Almost Withdrew Her!


It was revealed Black Caviar, the Australian wonder mare unbeaten in 22 starts, was almost scratched the evening before The Diamond Jubilee Stakes at Royal Ascot in June. Her trainer Peter Moody felt his stable star was not quite herself on the eve of 22nd June. He felt the need to ring his wife Sarah that evening to express his worry and to discuss the idea of withdrawing her.

Sarah said: 'You've got it right 21 times before but don't blame me if you stuff it up now!' In true Australian style.

Moody told a reporter: 'How close was I to scratching her? I don't know, but when you get a horse like her you get protective of her record and when they have soundness issues it probably always crosses your mind. At the end of the day I convinced myself she was good enough to get the job done and thankfully she was.

After her narrow success at Royal Ascot in June it appeared that Black Caviar wasn't her dominant self.

Moody continued: 'I possibly pushed her too hard before the race'.

Black Caviar is back in light training and has 21 days to prove to those who know her best that she wants to keep on racing. If she does she will come back to her regular work in November with a view to appear in the autumn (Australian autumn).

The mouth-watering clash between her and Frankel is almost certainly not going to happen. Although having watched the greatest horse of all time that is Frankel this summer, it's hard to argue that he would comfortably defeat the mare at whatever distance they were to compete over.


 However, whoever this guy is commentating on her 20th consecutive win in the above video has either got Tourette's, or can hardly see through his rose tinted glasses!

The commentary goes, I quote: 'She looks at the 30,000 strong crowd and says Jeez I'm good - no I'm not good, I'm the best you have ever seen in world!!'

Alright mate. Firstly, keep a lid on it. Secondly, watch Frankel's victories this summer and get your head out of your back side and smell the coffee.

Admittedly the above race was run before Frankel's excursions this summer, but the commentary is so over the top that it makes the above counter-argument irrelevant in my opinion.

She's good, very very good in fact. Although, nothing has ever been better than Frankel since ratings began. To say she is the 'best you have ever seen in the world' is entirely ludicrous and I'm glad his opinion hasn't been proven correct. Can you imagine the load of tripe he would come out with if that was the case!

Frankel. The best ever, without question.
Interestingly if we are measuring who is better by comparing the amount of Grade 1 victories each has won, regardless what horses they beat or have not beaten, Black Caviar is 3 ahead of Frankel.
  1. Black Caviar: 12 Grade 1 victories from 22 starts.
  2. Frankel: 9 Grade 1 victories from 13 starts.

But then if you are measuring Grade 1 victories to number of starts percentage:
  1. Black Caviar: 55%
  2. Frankel: 69%

At the end of the day you can discuss it until the sun sets. The correct conclusion is, undisputed, Frankel is the horse that the ridiculous commentary should be describing!

Is It Fair To Make A Pre-Conceived Judgement Of A Racehorse When They're Related To A Superstar?

Born To Sea was retired on Sunday morning having sustained an injury in the Red Mills Irish Champion Stakes.

Born To Sea trails Camelot in the Irish Derby
http://www.racingpost.com/horses/horse_home.sd?horse_id=773055#topHorseTabs=horse_race_record&bottomHorseTabs=horse_form

Owned by the Tsui family. Born To Sea carried the iconic yellow silks with a purple cap synonymous with his legendary half brother Sea The Stars and his Dam Urban Sea.

Finishing second last behind the irreplaceable Snow Fairy, Johnny Murtagh felt that his mount lost his action as the 3 year colt came passed the winning post. He was found to be lame behind on Sunday morning at John Oxx's yard and decision was made to end his racing career. Oxx felt the time frame to get Born To Sea fit again to meet his end of season targets was too slim bearing in mind he will require rest. However, the main reason to retire the colt was due to the large amount of interest in him as a stallion for next year. Where he will stand at stud is yet to be revealed.

Born To Sea was the last foal produced by the prolific Dam and 1993 Arc winner Urban Sea, who passed away whilst giving birth to the newly retired 3 year old.

In 8 starts Born To Sea won 1 race, a listed race at the Curragh as a 2 year old. The highlight of his racing career was surely a second place finish in the Irish Derby, behind potentially the first triple crown winner for 42 years in Camelot.

Perhaps it was disrespectful to mention Born To Sea in the same breath as Sea The Stars. Perhaps it was unfair to expect so much of him.

As his career draws to close I consider something.

In my opinion he was not Born To Sea the racehorse, his identity was the racehorse who was a half-brother to Sea The Stars.

Triple Gold Cup Winner Best Mate
I remember this type of situation occurring when Best Mate's full brother Inca Trail arrived at Henrietta Knight's yard in 2002. He was considered a big disappointment, when actually if he didn't have the tag of being a triple Gold Cup winners full brother, the publics view on Inca Trail's career might have been very different.

Inca Trail - unlucky to be Best Mate's full-brother?
More recently this applies to Born To sea too.

Is it fair to make a pre-conceived judgement of a racehorse when they're related to a superstar?

What was his name again?

Born To Sea The Stars.......it might as well have been.